• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Guytano's Pizza & Pasta: Authentic New York-Style Pizza & More in Lake Ronkonkoma

Guytano's Pizza & Pasta in Lake Ronkonkoma offers a fresh, inviting take on classic New York-style pizza and hearty Italian dishes. Known for its perfectly balanced pies—not too greasy, with flavorful sauces and crispy crusts—this spot stands out in a crowded market. Their chicken parm hero shines with juicy, well-breaded chicken and rich cheese on exceptional bread. Customers praise the friendly owner, quick service, and clean, welcoming atmosphere. Additions like flavorful wings and savory garlic knots elevate the menu. For those craving authentic, thoughtfully prepared pizza and pasta, Guytano’s delivers consistently satisfying, home-style flavors worth returning for.

Guytano's Pizza & Pasta at a glance

  • Address 708 Portion Rd, Lake Ronkonkoma, NY 11779, United States
  • Phone (631) 416-3314
  • Restaurant type Restaurant .

Photos & Gallery

Guytano's Pizza & Pasta: Reviews & Ratings

Andy
5

I came in today for my first time and tried them out. Solid New York style pizza, and few other options for specialty pies. Overall, the pizza was very good and not too greasy. The Environment was very clean and welcoming, and a very kind staff.

Jessica Hores
5

we went here the first time ever tonight. let me tell you Guytano is such a nice man and his pizza is splendid! my daughter(7) is a pizza connoisseur and this was amazing she said!! we loved the vibe when i called to the second i walked in, we will be using them as our new pizza go to! and the specials are great! so nice to meet you tonight Guytano! look forward to being a long time customer! congrats and good luck

Gail Graf
5

Great food. The best pizza in the area. Wings are fabulous, hot and fresh. I love the sauce for the garlic knots. Owner is very nice and takes care of his customers. We will be back to try more.

Kathy Thorbjornsen
5

Ive been a customer of another local pizza place for over 40 years. Lately the quality of the food has gone down while the prices keep rising. Heard about Guytanos on FB and decided to give it a try. I ordered a chicken parm hero for delivery. My food came faster than expected and it was hot and delicious. The chicken wasn't dry and the breading wasn't falling off. Perfectly cooked chicken, great sauce and a good amount of cheese all on incredible bread. I was so pleasantly surprised. I think I have found my new pizza place.

Laurie Hoffmann
5

We ordered takeout from here for the first time and will definitely be repeat customers. Food was delicious. Service was quick. And an added bonus is that they take credit card payment over the phone, which our other local spot does not.

Ben The Handyman
5

My first trip there today and I am an instant fan. The food is fresh hot and delicious. The service was fast and friendly. Nice to meet you today Guytano. Looking forward to exploring the menu. Thanks for a great lunch.

Deanna Shwonik
5

First time ordering from this establishment and wow! Amazing Brooklyn style pizza, great buffalo bites, open communication. Overall, great food so far.

Location

  • Guytano's Pizza & Pasta
    Guytano's Pizza & Pasta
    708 Portion Rd, Lake Ronkonkoma, NY 11779, United States Hotline: (631) 416-3314

Located in Lake Ronkonkoma, New York, Guytano's Pizza & Pasta is a standout destination for authentic New York-style pizza and hearty Italian fare. From the moment you step inside, the clean and welcoming atmosphere paired with the friendly service makes it clear that customer satisfaction is a priority here.

Guytano's pizza impresses with its perfectly balanced crust—crispy yet tender—and toppings that stay fresh without overwhelming greasiness. Specialty pies offer a flavorful twist, catering to both traditionalists and adventurous eaters alike. The wings, praised for their freshness and heat, complement the menu perfectly, as do the garlicky knots drenched in a robust sauce that adds a memorable punch.

The chicken parm hero deserves special mention; the juicy, well-breaded chicken layered with a rich sauce and ample cheese on fresh bread offers a comforting and satisfying meal. This dish, along with the efficient delivery service that ensures food arrives hot and promptly, elevates Guytano's beyond the typical pizza joint.

Customer feedback highlights not just the quality of food but the genuine warmth from the owner and staff—qualities that forge lasting relationships and loyal patrons. The convenient option to pay by credit card over the phone shows a thoughtful approach to modern customer needs, making every dining experience seamless and enjoyable.

For anyone seeking a reliable spot for delicious pizza, wings, and classic Italian dishes in the Lake Ronkonkoma area, Guytano's Pizza & Pasta promises not only great flavor but a dining experience built on care and authenticity. It’s no surprise that new visitors quickly become regular guests, drawn back by the consistent quality and the inviting vibe.

Business Information

  • Service options
    • Kerbside pickup
    • No-contact delivery
    • Delivery
    • Takeaway
    • Dine-in
  • Payments
    • Credit cards
    • Debit cards
    • Credit cards